Man’s $6M car collection brings thousands to museum in middle of nowhere

WEST OKOBOJI, Iowa — Tens of thousands of people travel every year to a classic car museum in the middle of nowhere.

Few people may consider West Okoboji, Iowa an obvious destination spot.

But there sits an estimated $6 million worth of inventory at Okoboji Classic Cars, owned by one man: Toby Shine.

He might be found at the end of a bar insidethe museum sipping a Bud Light, smoking a cigarette and wearing a smile.

Shine comes by in the afternoon to hang out and meet people who stop by what he calls his “man cave.” He doesn’t like the word museum, really. That sounds so stuffy. This place is like any single-story non-descript steel building from the outside. Inside, it’s filled with vehicles from every era, much like The Henry Ford Museum in Dearborn. But the difference is this is all owned by one man who figured it was a better way to store his collection than in warehouses all over the place.

Once word got out, people came. It never really was intended to be a museum-type deal. It opened to the public in 2013. Now his wife, Sylvia Shine, buys clothing and collectibles for the gift shop, non-profit organizations have big fundraisers there in gallery space near one of the vehicle exhibits with the ability to serve hundreds at a time after hours for dinner. The museum has its own kitchen and caters events with the staff of nearby Yesterdays restaurant.

The Shines, after meeting on a blind date, have been married 59 years.

Five stars

Okoboji Classic Cars attracts enthusiasts, historians, collectors and families looking for an unusual experience. On any given day, Shine displays 70 or so vehicles in two massive showrooms that are hand-painted with murals to recreate downtown Spencer, Iowa back from a time when America was first sending astronauts to the moon. There are old fashioned storefronts and signs. Spencer is where Shine was born in 1943.

“If I want to visit the names on those stores, I have to go the cemetery,” Shine said.

TripAdvisor gives the site a 5-star average from reviewers who say they’re wowed by 28,000 square feet of display.

“First time to a classic car museum. This place has set the bar so high,” wrote a Tampa, Florida visitor. “You need to see this place.”

Getting there isn’t easy.

You can fly into Sioux Falls, South Dakota or Des Moines, Iowa and rent a car and drive an hour or three.

Or you can just stop while passing through during a journey across America.

People hear about this unexpected tourist stop mostly by word of mouth, through social media and online classic car searches.

‘Captures your imagination’

Author John Dinges, an investigative reporter visiting from Washington, D.C., walked quickly to a Ford F-100 and said, “These were around when I was a kid. That’s a 1955 pickup. I was a freshman in high school. And you know what freshmen think about cars? Girls, that’s one thing, but cars? Oh my God, that’s really where your heart is.”

Dinges, who grew up the son of a Ford dealer in Emmetsburg, Iowa, then turned to say. “I want that 1966 (Chevy) Impala … It’s a convertible. It’s all white. The chrome sticks out about 8 inches on all sides. It’s just a marvelous, wonderful car. It captures your imagination to look at a car like that.”

Dinges, as well as a Free Press reporter and others, visited the museum as part of the annual Okoboji Writers’ Retreat this fall.

‘Force of nature’

Helen Miller, an eight-term former Democratic state representative from Fort Dodge, Iowa visited the classic car museum for the first time during the retreat.

It’s no surprise the collection is such a strong attraction after nearly a decade, she said. “Toby is a force of nature, just a plain old force of nature.”

Shine stood immediately upon seeing Miller, recognizing her and offering a big hug.

“I am seeing an unbelievable collection of cars, more than I ever imagined could be here,” she said.

The Henry Ford in Dearborn at age 5

Meanwhile, Andy Ross, a literary agent from Oakland, Calif., who owned Cody’s Books in Berkeley, strolled past a 1950 DeSoto and then a 1917 Buick.

“This reminds me of the car that Archduke Ferdinand and his wife were assassinated in Sarajevo in 1914, thus beginning World War I,” Ross said. “These cars are cool. When I was 5, I went to The Henry Ford Museum in Dearborn.”

From about 1960-64, his family lived in Detroit because his father left Neiman Marcus in Dallas to become president of Federal Department Stores.

“I was really into politics back then,” Ross said. “There was a guy running for governor, and I wanted to work for him. So I worked in his campaign headquarters in Detroit. I was running the mimeograph machine in George Romney’s office. I was 16 years old. One day, this kid came in and I was going to have to boss him around. It was the governor’s son. His name was Mitt. And I was Mitt’s boss. We spent the summer of 1962, I think, working together. I lived in Palmer Park. We were both 16.”

George Romney, a Republican, won two terms as governor and his son went on to seek the presidency.

A step back in time

Toby Shine, 79, wants people to reminisce when they step back in time.

More:General Motors’ private car museum has been a secret for years

More:Ford archivist warned everyone photo release would be popular. No one believed him