Buy Photo
Munro & Associates CEO Sandy Munro discusses design flaws he has found with the body of a Tesla Model 3 that was part of a reverse engineering event at Munro & Associates in Auburn Hills on Wednesday April 25, 2018.
(Photo: Mandi Wright, Detroit Free Press)Buy Photo
The Tesla Model 3 appears to be a tale of two cars.
Elon Musk’s vision of an electric vehicle for the masses pairs innovative electronics and interior material choices with basic car construction that puzzles the likes of Sandy Munro, whose Auburn Hills firm reverse-engineers products, including cars, working on everything from “Barbie to the space station.”
The engineers at Munro & Associates have been tearing into a Model 3 as they prepare an analysis they expect to have ready for sale by June. The firm bought the car in January from a private seller for $72,000.
On Wednesday morning, Munro showed a group of journalists and analysts with the Automotive Press Association around the body of a Model 3 stripped of its components, with a sleek, still-assembled black Model 3 sitting nearby.
“This is all dinosaur technology,” Munro said, referencing the stripped body.
Lots of steel, less aluminum, which makes the car heavier than might be expected. Munro also said the different types of welds surprised him.
“They don’t have a consistent way of doing things,” he said.
At various places on the body, white writing pointed out what Munro’s team found to be unusual:
“Too many parts.”
“Weld flanges too big.”
“Unusual to bolt here.”
Buy Photo
Munro & Associates senior lead design consultant Mark Ellis holds up a current collector from a battery on a Tesla Model 3 that was part of a reverse engineering event at Munro & Associates in Auburn Hills on Wednesday April 25, 2018.
(Photo: Mandi Wright, Detroit Free Press)
Munro & Associates also found much to like about the Model 3. A poster shows what is referred to as the Skateboard, an area that holds the car’s lengthy battery pack, calling it the “brilliance of the Tesla Model 3.”
Arrows pointed to parts of the diagram touting “excellent front suspension for a great drive,” “5 bar link for sport car handling” and “the electronic module center, we are shocked by the advanced integration and advanced manufacturing techniques.”
As Tesla CEO Musk’s ability to deliver on production promises for the Model 3 have consistently fallen short, the reasons could have much to do with basic carmaking. Musk, who famously described sleeping at his factory in Fremont, Calif., has said maybe the company used too many robots.
Read more:
Tesla CEO pay vs. Detroit 3 CEOs? They don’t compare
Tesla loses $619M in 3Q amid delays in Model 3 sedan
Top 10 dream cars: List starts with Mustang, Tesla, Jeep
Michelle Krebs, executive analyst at AutoTrader.com, suggested that the issues highlighted by Munro’s presentation appear to answer questions about Tesla’s production.
“This illustrates why Tesla has trouble building the Model 3 and why we’re hearing reports of poor quality,” Krebs said, noting that the company could have benefited from more automotive expertise. “They know how to do electronics very well. Detroit, Germany, Japan really know how to do the basic building blocks of a car.”
Munro was asked whether arrogance might have played a role in shaping the tech industry darling’s approach to automotive production, a relatively stodgy enterprise when compared with the shimmer of Silicon Valley.
“Arrogance is a disease,” Munro said, noting his own limitations. “Everybody I know who has too much arrogance always fails.”
Buy Photo
A stripped-down version of a Tesla Model 3 was part of a reverse engineering event at Munro & Associates in Auburn Hills on Wednesday, April 25, 2018.
(Photo: Mandi Wright, Detroit Free Press)
Tesla issued a statement about Munro’s conflicting impressions about the Model 3, noting recent improvements:
“The primary car evaluated by Munro was built in 2017. We have significantly refined our production processes since then, and while there’s always room for improvement, our data already shows that Model 3 quality is rapidly getting better. … Since we began shipping Model 3 last year, we have been very focused on refining and tuning both part and body manufacturing processes.”
The statement also discussed Tesla’s interest in safety.
“We stand behind our physical crash testing and our computer simulations of it, which have been remarkably accurate, and the safety that they demonstrate. The safety of our customers is more important than any other metric.”
Some of the more innovative aspects of what Tesla does were shown by Stephen Handley, a senior consultant for Munro.
Handley has years of experience with trim work through both Ford and General Motors.
He told a Free Press reporter to place his hands on a floor mat, which was sitting on a table, and push. The floor mat barely moved. Rather than relying on a hook or something similar to keep the floor mat in place, the Tesla solution used a unique material underneath.
Buy Photo
A Tesla Model 3 was part of a reverse engineering event at Munro & Associates in Auburn Hills on Wednesday April 25, 2018.
(Photo: Mandi Wright, Detroit Free Press)
“You don’t want your floor mat to slide up under your accelerator pedal,” Handley said. “They’ve got a lot of innovative stuff.”
Handley pointed to several examples:
A vinyl-like material that looks and feels similar to leather but isn’t.
A side seat trim assembly — typically a hard plastic piece that holds the controls on the side of a front seat — is one piece rather then three. It’s also flexible, so if a driver drops her keys, she can more easily retrieve them from under the seat.
A cross car beam, a part under the instrument panel, made of hydroformed aluminum overmolded with plastic, making it light and strong.
Handley joked about seeing the “Good, the Bad and the Ugly” in the Model 3, referencing the spaghetti Western starring Clint Eastwood, but he clearly likes what Tesla has done with its approach to trim.
“I hope they succeed. They’re an American car company,” Handley said.
Contact Eric D. Lawrence: elawrence@freepress.com. Follow him on Twitter: @_ericdlawrence.
Read or Share this story: https://on.freep.com/2HvcQoE