Not sure I remember this part of biology class!
Bee Kind
Bees are fish, corporations are people — and California, as always, is an entertaining mess.
A California appellate court ruled this week that bees can legally be classified as fish, a decision which — albeit in an incredibly roundabout and bureaucratic manner — is poised to help protect bees in the Golden State.
Although California’s Department of Fish and Wildlife considers a number of bee species to be “endangered,” there were no previous legal protections under the state’s Endangered Species Act (ESA), which only protects “native species or subspecies of a bird, mammal, fish, amphibian, reptile, or plant,” with no mention of insects.
What’s more, a number of lobbies across the state’s agricultural industry argued with an initial ruling in 2020 that would allow bees to be protected under the state’s ESA.
So, the bee advocates at the fascinatingly-named Xerces Society devised an ingenious yet bizarre workaround, Law & Crime notes — pointing out that the Fish and Game Code of the state’s ESA defines “fish” as anything that can be described as “a wild fish, mollusk, crustacean, invertebrate, amphibian, or part, spawn, or ovum of any of those animals.”
Spineless
You’ll remember from biology class, the Xerces Society argued, that bees are invertebrates by definition of not having spines. Though a district court agreed with this legal argument in 2020, a higher court overturned the ruling, which led these tireless bee stans to sue once more to have the appeal overruled.
In this latest ruling, the appellate court declared that the judiciary is “tasked with liberally construing” the state’s Endangered Species Act to make sure it’s effective.
There’s definitely some semantic issues with invertebrate classification — specifically, that 95 percent of all animal species fall within that category — that could lead to more trouble for this latest bee advocacy victory.
But for now, at least, things appear to be going swimmingly — or buzzingly, depending on who you ask.
READ MORE: California Court Paves the Way for Protection of Imperiled Bumble Bees and Other Insects [Xerces Society Invertebrate Conservation]
More on buzzy boys: Murder Hornets Have One Weakness, Scientists Say: Sex