Carlos Ghosn no longer capable of leading Renault, French finance minister says

Patrick T. Fallon | Bloomberg | Getty Images
Carlos Ghosn, chairman and chief executive officer of Nissan Motor Co. and Renault SA, speaks during the 2017 Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in Las Vegas, Nevada, U.S., on Thursday, Jan. 5, 2017.

Carlos Ghosn isn't currently fit to lead Renault following his arrest in Japan, French Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire has said.

Ghosn, who acts as CEO of Renault and chairman of both Renault and Nissan, was placed under arrest in Japan on Monday after he allegedly violated Japanese financial law. The arrest followed an investigation by a select number of people at Nissan.

The Japanese carmaker has said it will recommend that Ghosn be removed from his role and now attention has turned to what position Renault will take.

The French government has a 15 percent stake in Renault, which in turn holds a 43.4% stake in Nissan. French Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire has said Renault should now set up an interim management structure.

“Carlos Ghosn is no longer in a position capable of leading Renault,” Mr Le Maire told France Info radio on Tuesday.

Le Maire added that the French government had already investigated Ghosn's tax affairs but had found nothing wrong.

Nissan's Carlos Ghosn throws future of auto alliance into question
5:44 AM ET Tue, 20 Nov 2018 | 03:09

Overnight, shares of Nissan tumbled by 5.45 percent, while Mitsubishi, a third party in the auto alliance, tanked 6.85 percent. At the last check Renault shares were down more than 2 percent in European trade on Monday.

Ghosn joined Renault in 1996, then spearheaded the Renault – Nissan alliance in 2005 and led both firms through a turnaround. In 2016, Mitsubishi's inclusion helped expand the alliance. The three firms together account for one in every nine cars produced around the world.

Attention will now turn to how Renault treats the allegations of financial misconduct laid by both Nissan's executives and Japan's public prosecutor.

The company has confirmed to CNBC it will now meet on Tuesday night and also issued a short statement, defending its alliance with the Japanese firm.

“Pending provision of precise information from Carlos Ghosn, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Renault, the above directors wish to express their dedication to the defense of Renault's interest in the Alliance. The Board of Directors of Renault will be convened very shortly,” the statement read.

Auto alliance’s step not to back Ghosn could be key to its survival, says economist
5:36 AM ET Tue, 20 Nov 2018 | 02:35

Ana Nicholls, Managing Editor, Industry Briefing at the Economist Intelligence Unit told CNBC's Street Signs on Tuesday that Renault's apparent reluctance to back Ghosn would suggest that the alliance looks set to be protected.

Nicholls said she spoke to Ghosn last week and, coincidentally, discussed how the alliance would be shaped once he stepped down as the most senior executive.

“He said there was obviously other people within the group who had experience on both sides of the alliance who could take over,” she said.

Nicholls added that one obvious candidate to take over, at least at Renault, was Thierry Bollore, currently the French firm's chief operating officer.

The autos watcher added that within the overall alliance, the makeup of executives is currently “French heavy” and that could be set for change.

Fears that the Nissan scandal could threaten its global alliance are ‘overly alarmist’

Akio Kon | Bloomberg | Getty Images
Carlos Ghosn, chairman of Nissan Motor Co., speaks during an interview in Yokohama, Japan, on Thursday, Feb. 23, 2017.

The arrest of Carlos Ghosn, chairman of Nissan and a board member at Mitsubishi, has also thrown into question the future of the two companies' global alliance with French automaker Renault. But analysts say that's not likely.

Ghosn was arrested Monday amid allegations of financial misconduct, sending shares of the Japanese automakers on a downward spiral on Tuesday.

Nissan said in a statement Monday that “over many years,” Ghosn and board director, Greg Kelly, had been under-reporting compensation amounts to the Tokyo Stock Exchange securities report. According to Reuters, Japanese media said Ghosn had reported about 10 billion yen ($88.9 million) of annualcompensation as about 5 billion yen for several years.

Nissan Chief Executive Hiroto Saikawa, said at a Monday press conference that both men had been arrested and he was planning to propose to the board on Thursday to remove them from their roles. Mitsubishi also said that it would seek to remove Ghosn, who sits on its board of directors, from his current position at the company.

“We find media headlines saying that the alliance may fall to be overly alarmist.”
-Richard Hilgert, Morningstar

Shares of Nissan tumbled by 5.45 percent on Tuesday, while Mitsubishi tanked 6.85 percent. Renault shares were down more than 8 percent in European trade on Monday.

Alliance will likely continue

Ghosn is also the chairman and CEO Renault, and his arrest has thrown into question the future of the company's alliance with Nissan and Mitsubishi. He is also chairman and CEO of the alliance.

Renault owns 43.4 percent of Nissan, while Nissan owns 15 percent of Renault, with no voting rights in a partnership that began in 1999. Since 2016, Nissan has held a 34 percent controlling stake in its smaller Japanese rival, Mitsubishi.

Nissan Chairman Carlos Ghosn arrested for violating Japanese financial law
12:48 PM ET Mon, 19 Nov 2018 | 01:09

“While we view the allegations against Ghosn as a serious breach of shareholder trust in the senior leadership of not only Nissan but also the entire alliance, we find media headlines saying that the alliance may fall to be overly alarmist,” Richard Hilgert, a senior equity analyst at Morningstar, said in a note.

“The scandal represents substantial key-man risk to the alliance but, in our opinion, the risk does not rise to the level of existential,” he said.

Another analyst also told CNBC's that the alliance will likely continue despite Ghosn's arrest.

“Our belief is that the alliance will continue to pursue the joint activities,” said Janet Lewis, head of industrials research, Asia, at Macquarie Capital Securities on “Squawk Box” Tuesday. “It did not depend on one person, there are hundreds of Renault and Mistubishi and Nissan employees working together on these projects.”

“The degree of integration at lower levels is substantial, nobody wins if they decide to, to move away,” she said.

'Truly shocking'

The latest fiasco surprised some analysts.

“It's truly shocking,” Rebecca Lindland, executive analyst at Kelley Blue Book, told CNBC's “Street Signs” Tuesday in response to the allegations against Ghosn.

“To see this, to hear this unfold. It's just, it's terrible,” she added. “It's such … a disgrace in many ways and such a waste of an incredible career.”

Morningstar's Hilgert echoed Lindland's sentiment.

“The news was a complete shock to us,” Hilgert said in his note. “We had respected Ghosn as an adept industry operator and credit him with an impressive turnaround at Nissan in the early 2000s, as well as building the Renault- Nissan-Mitsubishi alliance.”

— CNBC's David Reid and Robert Ferris, and Reuters contributed to this report.

Ghosn's alleged scheme cost Nisson 'millions'

Ghosn's alleged scheme cost Nisson 'millions'Yokohama, Japan – Nissan Chairman Carlos Ghosn, who became one of the auto industry’s most powerful executives by engineering a turnaround at the Japanese manufacturer, was arrested Monday and will be fired for allegedly underreporting his income and misusing company funds, the automaker said.
The scandal reverberated across the globe and abruptly threw into question Ghosn’s future as leader of the Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi alliance, which sold 10.6 million cars last year, more than any other manufacturer.
Nissan CEO Hiroto Saikawa said Ghosn was taken into custody after being questioned by prosecutors upon arriving in Japan earlier in the day. Ghosn is of French, Brazilian and Lebanese background and lives in both France and Japan.
Nissan said Ghosn, 64, and another senior executive, Greg Kelly, were accused of offenses involving millions of dollars that were discovered during a monthslong investigation set off by a whistleblower. Kelly was also arrested.
“Beyond being sorry I feel great disappointment, frustration, despair, indignation and resentment,” Saikawa said, apologizing for a full seven minutes at the outset of a news conference.
Yokohama-based Nissan Motor said it is cooperating with prosecutors in their investigation.
Read: Disgraced pioneering UAW official faces reckoning
Saikawa said Nissan’s board will vote Thursday on dismissing Ghosn and Kelly, whom he described as the mastermind of the alleged abuses.
“This is an act that cannot be tolerated by the company,” he said. “This is serious misconduct.”
Saikawa said three major types of misconduct were found: underreporting income to financial authorities, using investment funds for personal gain and illicit use of company expenses.
He said that because of the continuing investigation, he could not disclose many details. But he promised to tighten internal controls, saying the problems may have happened because too much power was concentrated in one person.
“We need to really look back at what happened, take it seriously and take fundamental countermeasures,” he said.
Read: Corrupt Fiat Chrysler exec gets 5.5 years in prison
Ghosn officially still leads the Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi alliance as CEO and chairman. But experts said it is unlikely he will be able to stay on there or at Renault, where he is also CEO. Renault said its board will hold an emergency meeting soon.
“The last thing one of the world’s biggest automakers needs is the disruption caused by an investigation into the behavior of a man who has towered over the global auto sector,” said Michael Hewson, chief market analyst at CMC Markets in London.
The companies in the alliance own parts of each other and share investments in new technologies, among other things. Renault owns 43 percent of Nissan, which owns 15 percent of Renault and 34 percent of Mitsubishi.
Renault SA stock plunged more than 8 percent in France. Japanese markets had already closed when the scandal broke.
Ghosn was at Nissan for 19 years and signed a contract this year that would have run through 2022. His compensation, high by Japanese standards, has been a source of controversy over the years.
According to NHK and the Kyodo News Service, Nissan paid Ghosn nearly 10 billion yen ($89 million) over five years through March 2015, including salary and other income, but he reported receiving only about half that amount.
The allegations are a serious blow at a time when Nissan is still getting over a scandal in which it admitted altering the results of emission and fuel economy tests on vehicles sold in Japan.
Ghosn is credited with helping bring about a remarkable turnaround at Nissan, resuscitating it from near bankruptcy by cutting thousands of jobs and shutting plants. His triumph made him something of a national hero in a country where foreign CEOs of major Japanese companies are relatively rare.
He also looms large in France, where he previously turned Renault around and made it into a global player, notably in electric vehicles. He led the French carmaker through major job cuts and an expensive and contentious bailout, earning the nickname “Le Cost Cutter.”
Ghosn became a nemesis of French unions and left-wing politicians, who saw him as a symbol of capitalism’s excesses, particularly its rich executive pay packages.
Renault shareholders in 2016 voted against Ghosn’s pay package as too generous, but the board ignored the move.
That angered then-President Francois Hollande. Hollande’s socialist government imposed limits on executive pay at state-run companies and tried to do the same in the private sector but backed down amid concerns such action would scare away foreign investment.
Ghosn served as Nissan’s chief executive from 2001 until last April. He became chief executive of Renault in 2005, leading the two major automakers simultaneously. In 2016, he became Mitsubishi Motors’ chairman.
Saikawa said the scandal was a “negative outcome of the long regime of Mr. Ghosn.”
Mari Yamaguchi in Tokyo and Angela Charlton in Paris contributed to this report.
Read or Share this story: https://www.detroitnews.com/story/business/autos/foreign/2018/11/19/nissan-dismiss-ghosn-misconduct/38562173/

Ghosn’s arrest casts doubt on Renault-Nissan alliance

Ghosn’s arrest casts doubt on Renault-Nissan allianceDetroit – For years, France’s Renault and Japan’s Nissan struggled to make money in the global auto business.
Then came Carlos Ghosn, a Renault executive who helped to orchestrate an unprecedented transcontinental alliance, combining parts of both companies to share engineering and technology costs.
Now Ghosn’s arrest in Japan for alleged financial improprieties at Nissan could put the nearly 20-year-old alliance in jeopardy.
Ghosn, 64, born in Brazil, schooled in France and of Lebanese heritage, is set to be ousted this week from his spot as Nissan chairman. He could also lose his roles as CEO and chairman of Renault, threatening the alliance formed in 1999 that’s now selling more than 10 million automobiles a year.
He’s been “the glue that holds Renault and Nissan together,” Bernstein analyst Max Warburton wrote in a note to investors. “It is hard not to conclude that there may be a gulf opening up between Renault and Nissan.”
Nissan has said it will dismiss Ghosn after he was arrested for allegedly abusing company funds and misreporting his income. That opens up a leadership void at the entire alliance, for which Ghosn officially still serves as CEO and chairman.
Ghosn added Mitsubishi to the alliance two years ago after the tiny automaker was caught in a gas-mileage cheating scandal. He had even floated the idea of a full merger between the three companies.
“Today’s events throw any prospect of that up in the air,” Michael Hewson, chief market analyst at CMC Markets in London, wrote in a note to investors.
Nissan CEO Hiroto Saikawa has publicly resisted the idea of an outright merger. So with Ghosn out at Nissan and probably Renault as well, the companies are unlikely to get any closer.
The companies now share technology, and they save money by jointly purchasing components.
While there could be some scrutiny of the relationships between the companies, they’re so intertwined now that cutting them apart would be difficult, said Kelley Blue Book analyst Michelle Krebs. “I would not predict its demise,” Krebs said of the alliance.
She said she sees further consolidation in an industry that faces unprecedented research costs for autonomous and electric vehicles, while at the same time continuing to develop cars and trucks powered by internal combustion engines.
“The last thing one of the world’s biggest automakers needs is the disruption caused by an investigation into the behavior of a man who has towered over the global auto sector,” said Hewson.
Nissan’s board is to meet Thursday to consider Ghosn’s fate. Renault, where Ghosn is also CEO, said its board will hold an emergency meeting soon, and experts say it is unlikely that he will be able to stay at the company or the broader alliance.
The brash Ghosn was once viewed as a savior in the auto business with the ability to turn around the two struggling companies. In 2006 he even proposed an alliance with global giant General Motors.
Bernstein’s Warburton wrote that Ghosn’s once-mighty reputation has been declining for years, while Krebs said Nissan never could meet Ghosn’s goal of 10 percent U.S. market share even though it has relied on “bad behavior” such as heavy discounts and sales to rental car companies.
Saikawa reiterated Nissan’s commitment to the venture, while a Renault statement expressed “dedication to the defense of Renault’s interest in the alliance.”
––––
Charlton reported from Paris. News Researcher Rhonda Shafner contributed from New York.
Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Read or Share this story: https://www.detroitnews.com/story/business/autos/foreign/2018/11/20/ghosns-arrest-casts-doubt-renault-nissan-alliance/38570467/

Congress considers extending electric vehicle tax credits, approval of self-driving cars

Congress considers extending electric vehicle tax credits, approval of self-driving carsWashington — With Congress returning to Washington on Tuesday for a flurry of legislative activity before the end of the year, transportation advocates are hoping to win support for pair of measures that would allow carmakers to sell thousands of self-driving cars and extend tax credits for electric vehicles.
Supporters of a U.S. Senate bill championed by U.S. Sen. Gary Peters, D-Bloomfield Township, that would allow automakers to sell more than 80,000 self-driving cars each per year are hoping to finally pass the measure in the upcoming so-called lame duck session after a year-long wait. They note that the current Republican-led House passed a similar measure with relative ease in 2017.
Additionally, General Motors Co., Nissan Motor Co. and Tesla Inc. have joined forces with environmental groups to form a new coalition that is pushing to remove a cap on a federal tax credit that provides up to $7,500 to buyers of electric cars. GM, Nissan and Tesla, makers of the Chevrolet Bolt, Nissan Leaf and Tesla's electric-fleet, are among the biggest electric car producers in the U.S. Current rules allow automakers to offer credits for up to 200,000 electric vehicles per manufacturer.
Republican senators may be more likely to compromise with their Democratic colleagues on the self-driving legislation instead of waiting to have to negotiate a new deal with the House after Democrats take control of that chamber in January.
A spokeswoman for Peters said he “continues to work with his colleagues on both sides of the aisle” to get the bill signed into law before the end of the year, noting that major companies have already begun testing autonomous vehicles at several sites around the U.S., including at the American Center for Mobility in Ypsilanti Township.
“As companies move forward with their self-driving vehicle plans, Sen. Peters is focused on ensuring there is a federal regulatory framework in place to oversee the safe deployment of self-driving vehicles,” Peters' office said.
But critics of the bill argue that not enough attention is being paid to safety concerns, and that there isn't enough oversight on the road-readiness of the technology.
The picture is slightly more complicated for supporters of lifting the cap on electric car tax credits. A measure by U.S. Sen. John Barrasso, R-Wy., would eliminate the tax credit for electric cars and institute a new tax on electric cars and alternative fuel vehicles to boost the coffers of the federal Highway Trust Fund that pays for construction projects.
A separate measure by U.S. Sen. Dean Heller, R-Nev., would keep the electric vehicle tax credit in place and lift the cap. A similar measure was also introduced by U.S. Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., Jeff Merkley, D-Ore., Martin Heinrich, D-N.M. and Catherine Cortez Masto, D-Nev.
Heller lost his seat in last week's election to Democratic U.S. Rep. Jackie Rosen, who has also co-sponsored legislation in the House to extend the electric car tax credit for 10 years. Nevada is home to Tesla's Gigafactory 1 lithium-ion battery factory.
When carmakers hit the 200,000-vehicle ceiling, they face a phasing-out process of the $7,500 tax credit offered to buyers of full-electric vehicles — reducing that credit by half every six months. At least one automaker, Tesla, has already hit the limit, and GM is also expected to hit the mark during the fourth quarter of 2018.
GM sold 23,297 all-electric Chevrolet Bolts and 20,349 plug-in hybrid Chevrolet Volts in the U.S. in 2017.
Dan Turton, vice president of public policy at GM, said in announcing a new group known as the EV Drive Coalition that includes GM, Nissan and Tesla: “A federal tax credit to help make electric vehicles more affordable for all consumers is integral to reaching a zero-emissions future and establishing the U.S. as the leader in electrification. We feel that the tax credit should be modified so all customers continue to receive the full benefit going forward.”
Advocates for the self-driving bill are hoping for favorable action. Scott Hall, director of communications and public affairs of the Washington, D.C.-based Alliance for Automobile Manufacturers, which lobbies for major U.S. and foreign-owned automakers, said automakers “remain optimistic the Senate will take action on this bipartisan legislation, given the tremendous promise of this technology to make our roadways safer and provide greater mobility options to persons with disabilities and seniors.”
But critics of the self-driving bill are on high alert.
John Simpson, privacy and technology project director at the Los Angeles-based Consumer Watchdog group, which has raised concerns about the safety of self-driving cars after recent high-profile crashes, said he is “concerned there will be a mad rush to try to slam it through” now that the contentious election season has passed.
“It's simply insanity to rush through a bad bill just to say you've got a bill,” Simpson said, adding that Congress has done little to address concerns that have been raised by safety groups about giving automakers wide latitude to sell self-driving cars.
Groups that represent trial lawyers have complained about a lack of protections that would ensure the right to sue if someone is hurt or killed in a self-driving car.
Peter Knudsen, director of communications for the Washington, D.C-based American Association for Justice, which lobbies for trial lawyers who typically represent plaintiffs, added that his group is also still “strongly opposed” to the Senate's self-driving bill.
“We remain hopeful that proponents of AV START will adopt the vital changes necessary to ensure that the bill brings transparency and accountability to the driverless car industry,” Knudsen said.
The arguments appear to have held sway with some U.S. senators thus far. At least five have publicly expressed concerns about the measure, pointing to accidents this year that involved Uber and Tesla vehicles that were operating autonomously or semi-autonomously. The opposition prevented the self-driving bill from being quickly passed in the notoriously deliberate upper chamber.
klaing@detroitnews.com
(202) 662-8735
Twitter: @Keith_Laing
Read or Share this story: https://www.detroitnews.com/story/business/autos/mobility/2018/11/20/driverless-electric-vehicle-bills-face-lame-duck-rush/1991341002/

Carlos Ghosn Is Removed as Chairman of Mitsubishi Motors

TOKYO — Carlos Ghosn, one of the auto industry’s most powerful leaders, lost another title on Monday when the board of Mitsubishi Motors removed him as chairman, one week after he was arrested in Tokyo on suspicion of financial misconduct. Mr. Ghosn, who was stripped of the chairmanship of Nissan last week in a unanimous… Continue reading Carlos Ghosn Is Removed as Chairman of Mitsubishi Motors

Top Automotive Industry News for Week of November 19 – November 25, 2018

Here is the most important news associated with the automotive industry
identified by the AEA for the week of November 19, 2018 -November 25, 2018.

We hope it helps you stay up to speed on the key developments in our
industry:

-Automotive Manufacturing News-

Ford, VW could announce electric, driverless-car collaborations:
analyst

(MarketWatch)

Ford wants to get rid of that new-car smell. Here's why.

(USA Today)

General Motors buyouts likely to fall short and layoffs loom

(USA Today)

German court rules Volkswagen must reimburse owner full price of car

(Reuters)

Ghosn scandal could trigger a series of crises for Nissan, Renault,
Mitsubishi

(CNBC)

GM under investigation for faulty brake vacuum pumps

(Detroit Free Press)

Mazda Toyota Manufacturing kicks off construction on $1.6B Alabama
plant

(Made In Alabama)

Nissan board votes to remove Carlos Ghosn as chairman

(CNBC)

Renault taps interim chairman, COO to replace Ghosn: sources

(Reuters)

Tesla will cut prices in China in response to import tariffs; Reuters

(MarketWatch)

These are the best cars we tested in 2018

(CNBC)

-Automotive Evolution News-

AEye Raises $40M To Build Autonomous Car Sensor That Sees Better Than
Humans

(Forbes)

China Is Leading the World to an Electric Car Future

(Bloomberg)

Congress considers extending electric vehicle tax credits, approval of
self-driving cars

(The Detroit News)

Electric vehicle sales to 'see a big lift' over the next 2 to 3 years,
BlackRock says

(CNBC)

Needing Growth, Uber Returns to Germany. This Time on Best Behavior.

(The New York Times)

-Automotive Retail News-

3 straight quarters of more than 10 million used-car sales

(Auto Remarketing)

Analysts Expect First November Car Sales Slide in 9 Years

(The Detroit Bureau)

AutoNation and Scott Painter patch things up

(Automotive News)

Black Friday is breathing life back into the 0% auto loan

(Automotive News)

Digital Crystal Ball Gives Auto Dealers A View To Future Sales

(Forbes)

Every Plug-In-Hybrid Vehicle Available in America Today

(Car and Driver)

What's the Best New-Car Deal for Black Friday?

(Cars.com)

Where the deals are for Black Friday car shopping

(CNBC)

-Automotive Wholesale News-

J.D. Power’s wholesale price projection through 2019

(Auto Remarketing)

Update on late-model auction volume

(Auto Remarketing)

Used cars with the least depreciation in 2018

(Autoblog)

-Automotive Enthusiast News-

23 hot cars we can't wait to see at the 2018 LA Auto Show

(Business Insider)

-Automotive Servicing News-

Citing Brake Concern, Feds Investigate 2.7M Pickups, Sport Utes

(Forbes)

-General Business & Executive News-

An early holiday gift: Lower gas, oil prices could boost spending,
economy

(USA Today)

Billionaire threatens to tackle the nation’s most expensive auto
insurance

(Insurance Business)

On Black Friday, more U.S. shoppers chose the computer over the mall

(Reuters)

PureCars launches an attribution platform just for car dealerships

(MarTech)

Tesla is turning to partners to help with a growing used-car business

(CNBC)

U.S. retail sales rebound, but consumer spending slowing

(Reuters)

-AEA Reminder-

Did we miss something? Let us know via our

Contact Us Page >>

. If you have specific important news going public soon that you would like
to share with your fellow AEA Members, submit your

PR Distribution Request >>

Have a great week,

Member Services

memberservices@automotiveexecutives.com

Automotive Executives Association

www.automotiveexecutives.com

Carlos Ghosn sacked as Mitsubishi Motors chairman

Carlos Ghosn Carmaker’s board follows Nissan in ousting executive after misconduct allegations Mitsubishi Motors’ Carlos Ghosn has been accused of under-reporting his income by millions of dollars. Photograph: Etienne Laurent/EPA Carlos Ghosn has been sacked as chairman of Mitsubishi Motors, a week after he was arrested over allegations that he under-reported his income by millions… Continue reading Carlos Ghosn sacked as Mitsubishi Motors chairman

Mitsubishi Electric and NTT DOCOMO announce successful 5G throughput in outdoor trials

Mitsubishi Electric Corporation and NTT DOCOMO, INC. announced the fifth-generation (5G) mobile telecommunications proof of concept for 27Gbps and 25Gbps maximum throughputs via one mobile terminal over communication distances of 10m and 100m, respectively, using the 28GHz radio frequency. The demonstration was conducted during joint outdoor field trials using 28GHz-band massive-element antenna systems and 16-beam… Continue reading Mitsubishi Electric and NTT DOCOMO announce successful 5G throughput in outdoor trials